Name of Tenderer:

China Road and Bridge Corporation – CCCC THIRD HIGHWAY ENGINEERING CO. LTD Joint Venture

Country:

China/China

Contract Price:

Lot 1  49, 213, 993.80 (forty-nine million two hundred thirteen thousand nine hundred ninety-three and eighty cents United States Dollar)

Lot2  25,793,630.01 (twenty-five million, seven hundred ninety-three thousands, six  hundred thirty and one cent United States Dollar)

Lot 3 47,250,328.56 (Forty-seven million two hundred fifty thousand three hundred twenty-eight and fifty-six cents United States Dollar)

Name of Tenderer

Country

Technical Score

Tender Price as Read Out (currency)

Tender Price as Evaluated (currency)

Financial Score

Total Score

Ranking

JV "Sinohydro Co., Ltd." and "Sinohydro Bureau 10 Co., Ltd"

China

NA

Lot1

49,453,999.23 (USD)

Lot1

47,548,645.08 (USD)

NA

NA

Lot 2

31,148,865.61 (USD)

Lot 2

29,909,712.01 (USD)

Lot3

 51,300,832.69 (USD)

Lot3

51,300,842.58 (USD)

JV "China Railway Sixth Group Co. Ltd. " and "China Railway Major Bridge Engineering Group Co., Ltd. "

China

NA

Lot2

30,985,913.91 (USD)

Lot2

30,985,913.92 (USD)

NA

NA

Lot 3

55,258,620.34 (USD)

Lot 3

55,258,620.35 (USD)

China Road and Bridge Corporation-CCCC THIRD HIGHWAY ENGINEERING CO., LTD   JV

China

NA

Lot1 49,213,993.80 (USD)

Lot1

49,213,993.80 (USD)

NA

NA

Lot2

25,793,630.01 (USD)

Lot2

25,793,630.01 (USD)

Lot3

47,250,328.56 (USD)

Lot3

47,250,328.56 (USD)

Name of Tenderer

Country

Tender Price as Read Out (currency)

Brief Reasons for Rejection

JSC "K-Dorstroy"

Kazakhstan

-

Bank guarantee does not comply; Financial position and financial indicators do not meet the requirements.

"Construction consortium of "K-Dorstroy JSC, Bazis Construction LLP" JV

Kazakhstan/Kazakhstan

-

Bank guarantee does not comply;

Financial position and financial indicators do not meet the requirements.

Hebei Construction Group Co., Ltd

China

-

Due to the refusal of further participation, the bidder's proposals are rejected

JV LLP "Sine Midas Stroy"

Kazakhstan

-

Financial resources do not match requirements.

China Railway 20th Bureau Group Co., Ltd.

China

-

Does not match. requirements in terms of specific experience

JV "Metag Insaat Ticaret A.S. " &

Turkey/Azerbaijan

-

There is a history of non-performance of contracts, as well as confirmed falsification of data. Financial position and financial performance are inadequate.

"OJSC Akkord Industry Construction Investment Corp

Azerbaijan

-

There is a history of non-performance of contracts, as well as confirmed falsification of data. Financial position and financial performance are inadequate

Onur Taahhut Tasimacilik Insaat Ticaret ve Sanayi A.S.

Turkey

-

Financial position and financial indicators do not meet the requirements.

LLP "Avtodorservice firm"

Kazakhstan

-

Bank guarantee does not comply.

Financial position and financial indicators do not meet the requirements

Longjian Road & Bridge Co., Ltd.

China

-

Financial resources do not match requirements

- Doesn't match. Requirements in terms of specific experience.

Zhongmei Engineering Group Ltd

China

-

Financial Proposal and Technical Proposal were in the same file. Rejected at the preliminary review stage.

CITIC CONSTRUCTION CO., LTD

China

-

Does not match. Requirements in terms of specific experience.

DOGUS INSAAT VE TICARET A.S.

Turkey

-

Deviations from the tender offer Tender Security

Tunnel Sadd Ariana-Khaneh Gostar Gil JV

Iran/Tajikistan

-

Financial Proposal and Technical Proposal were in the same file. Rejected at the preliminary review stage

Joint Venture of PARS TABLEAU and PANORAMA BALCON AL MAR, S.A.

Iran/Spain

-

Proposal rejected at the preliminary review stage. Proposal is not submitted in accordance with the established requirements